Tuesday, May 20, 2014

Black Return Migration to the South

In recent years sociologists and demographers have noted increased internal migration of native-born black Americans who relocate from northern to southern destinations; and increased black migration to Atlanta is part of this trend. Black migration to the South has increased each decade since the early 1970s, when the economic boom that attracted African Americans from the South to the cities of North, Midwest, and West ended (Dodson and Diouf 2004; Population Reference Bureau 2000).[1] By 1970, the number of African Americans moving to the South surpassed the number migrating out. A report by the Population Reference Bureau (2000) stated that “by the 1990s, the South was experiencing a net increase in black migrants from all other regions.” New black communities have been emerging all over the South due to the mass migration of African Americans to the region (Morehouse 2009). Researchers have referred to the migration as “return migration” or the “New Great Migration,” since in some cases, migrants were returning to the hometowns of their parents or grandparents who left the South during the Great Migration of the early 1900s and the Second Great Migration of the World War II-era (Dodson and Diouf 2004; Frey 2004; Morehouse 2009). However, this flow may be misnamed, for many of these internal migrants have no roots in the communities where they settle (Dodson and Diouf 2004; Falk, Hunt, and Hunt 2004).
Studies of the return migration offer a variety of reasons for the movement of African Americans to the South. Howard Dodson and Sylviane A. Diouf (2004) report that return migration was initially generated by familial reasons, such as having to care for a sick or elderly relative or wanting to be closer to family, but as the migration grew, it became largely influenced by economic and nonfamily-related social reasons. The deindustrialization of northern cities in the 1970s, coupled with the South’s growing job market and its improved racial climate, has attracted hundreds of thousands of African Americans to the region. Dodson and Diouf (2004) assert that some migrants were also moving to the South to escape the crime and the worsening conditions of the urban North, and that some were moving to the region to retire in a place with a better quality of life than they had experienced in the North[2]. Anthropologist Carol Stack (1996) argues that the migrants are drawn by a “call to home” from the South, which holds a definitive place in the history and collective memory of African Americans, as a place where their roots run deep. Atlanta, in particular, has received a significant portion of the return migrants.
Atlanta has long been known as a center of black wealth, higher education, political power, culture, and entrepreneurship in the US (Dodson and Diouf 2004; Leung 2003; Whitaker 2002). The Atlanta University Center, consisting of four highly accredited schools (Morehouse College, Morehouse School of Medicine, Spelman College, and Clark Atlanta University), is the largest consortium of African American higher education in the world. The 1973 election of the city’s first black mayor, Maynard H. Jackson Jr., ushered in a new era in city politics; since then, African Americans have had significant power over the city’s government, shifting power from Atlanta’s white elite to its growing black middle class. Nearly 160,000 black Americans moved to Atlanta between 1990 and 1999, leading some to refer to the city as “the Harlem of the 1990s” (Dodson and Diouf 2004) or the “New Black Mecca” (Leung 2003; Whitaker 2002).
Research on black migration to the South has mostly followed a “return home” model that assumes the migrants have southern roots, solidifying the perception that this migration is a “return migration” (Dodson and Diouf 2004; Frey 2004; Morehouse 2009; Stack 1996). However, this model ignores that many of the “return” migrants have never lived in the South before they moved there, or have no familial ties to the region. By using the return home model, scholars overlook the intra-racial ethnic diversity of black migration to the South. Afro-Caribbeans are among the southern-bound black migrants that do not fit the return home model; yet, they are most likely included in the research data of “return” migrants to the South. It is a mistaken assumption rooted in methodology, since the census numbers most researchers look at for “race,” not ancestry, makes it hard to distinguish southern-origin African Americans from others.




[1] World War II and the availability of jobs in factories and plants in the cities of the Midwest, the North, and the West heavily generated the economic boom (Dodson and Diouf 2004).
[2] Frey (1999) finds that states that received a large number of migrants during the Great Migrations to the North are among the top donor states in the return migration to the South. 

No comments:

Post a Comment